You’re building an audience, and you know you need an email list. But which platform should you choose? Mailchimp is the name everyone recognizes, ConvertKit is everywhere in the creator space, and Beehiiv keeps showing up in conversations about newsletters.
The problem isn’t just picking a tool. It’s that these platforms serve slightly different purposes, and choosing the wrong one means either paying for features you’ll never use or hitting walls when you try to grow. If you’re a solo creator publishing a newsletter, running a course, or building a personal brand, the differences matter more than the marketing pages suggest.
Here’s what each platform actually does well, where they fall short, and which one fits different types of solo creators.
| Tool | Best for | Free tier | Starting price |
|---|---|---|---|
| Mailchimp | General marketing emails | 500 contacts | $13/month (500 contacts) |
| ConvertKit | Course creators, bloggers | 1,000 subscribers | $25/month (1,000 subscribers) |
| Beehiiv | Newsletter publishers | 2,500 subscribers | $39/month (10,000 subscribers) |
Mailchimp: The All-Purpose Option That Shows Its Age
Mailchimp started as an email marketing platform for businesses, and it still shows. You get campaigns, automation, landing pages, and analytics. The interface is familiar if you’ve used any marketing software before. It works for product launches, promotional emails, and general business communication.
The free tier gives you 500 contacts and 1,000 monthly email sends, which is enough to start. But it’s limited. You can’t A/B test subject lines, you can’t remove Mailchimp branding, and automation options are basic. The free tier feels like a trial more than a real option.
Once you pay, you get access to better automation, multivariate testing, and send-time optimization. The Standard plan starts at $13/month for 500 contacts, but pricing scales quickly. At 5,000 subscribers, you’re looking at $75/month. At 10,000, it’s $138/month.
Where Mailchimp Works
Mailchimp makes sense if you’re sending promotional emails, product updates, or marketing campaigns. It integrates with e-commerce platforms, has solid segmentation, and offers pre-built templates for different business types. If you’re running a product-based business or need robust e-commerce integration, Mailchimp handles that well.
The analytics go deeper than basic open and click rates. You can track revenue per campaign, see purchase behavior, and segment based on engagement. For someone selling products or services, this data matters.
Where It Falls Short
For newsletter creators, Mailchimp feels clunky. The editor is built for marketing emails, not long-form content. You’re working with drag-and-drop blocks designed for promotional layouts, not articles. There’s no native newsletter archive, no subscription widget that feels modern, and no built-in referral system.
The pricing also penalizes growth. Every time you add subscribers, your bill increases. For creators trying to build large audiences, this gets expensive fast. And the interface, while functional, hasn’t kept pace with newer tools built specifically for creators.
ConvertKit: Built for Creators Who Sell
ConvertKit was designed for bloggers, course creators, and digital product sellers from the start. The whole platform assumes you’re building an audience to eventually monetize. You get landing pages, forms, automation sequences, and a visual automation builder that’s easier to understand than Mailchimp’s.
The free tier supports up to 1,000 subscribers with unlimited email sends. You can build landing pages, create basic forms, and send broadcasts. You don’t get automation on the free plan, but for starting out, it’s functional.
Paid plans start at $25/month for 1,000 subscribers. You get full automation, the visual automation builder, advanced reporting, and email support. At 5,000 subscribers, you pay $66/month. At 10,000, it’s $116/month.
Where ConvertKit Excels
The tagging and segmentation system is powerful without being complicated. Instead of managing complex lists, you tag subscribers based on interests, purchases, or behavior. This makes it easy to send targeted content without creating list management chaos.
The automation builder is visual and intuitive. You can see the flow of emails, add conditional logic, and tag subscribers based on their actions. For course creators or anyone selling digital products, this matters. You can create sequences that deliver content, follow up with non-buyers, or segment based on engagement.
ConvertKit also offers a creator network feature and paid newsletter options. If you want to charge for your newsletter or get discovered by other creators’ audiences, it’s built in. The landing page builder is simple but effective, and forms embed cleanly anywhere.
If you’re interested in automating your email follow-up process as part of a larger lead capture system, this guide on automating lead capture covers the broader workflow.
Where It Disappoints
ConvertKit isn’t great for newsletter publishing as a primary focus. There’s no built-in archive page that looks good, no native referral program (though you can build one with automations), and the email editor, while clean, isn’t as polished for long-form content as dedicated newsletter platforms.
The design templates are minimal, which is fine for some creators but limiting if you want more visual flexibility. And while the automation is powerful, it requires setup time. You’re not getting plug-and-play solutions; you’re building workflows yourself.
Beehiiv: The Newsletter-First Platform
Beehiiv launched in 2021, built specifically for newsletter creators. Everything about it assumes you’re publishing regular content to an audience. You get a built-in website, automatic archive pages, subscriber referral programs, ad network access, and analytics designed for content performance.
The free tier is generous: 2,500 subscribers with unlimited sends. You get the newsletter editor, basic analytics, and a simple website. No landing pages on the free tier, but you can embed signup forms. It’s enough to publish and grow without paying.
The Scale plan costs $39/month and supports up to 10,000 subscribers. You get the referral program, custom domains, audience segmentation, and the ability to remove branding. At 25,000 subscribers, you’re looking at $99/month. The Max plan at $99/month (for 100,000 subscribers) adds monetization tools, priority support, and advanced analytics.
Where Beehiiv Shines
The writing experience is better than both Mailchimp and ConvertKit. The editor is clean, supports rich media easily, and formats long-form content well. Your newsletters automatically create archive pages that look good. The built-in website means you don’t need a separate platform for hosting your newsletter publicly.
The referral program is native and works well. You can set up reward tiers, track who’s referring subscribers, and automate rewards. For creators focused on growing their newsletter, this is a real advantage. Other platforms require third-party tools or manual tracking.
Beehiiv also offers an ad network. If you hit their subscriber thresholds, you can monetize through their platform without negotiating deals yourself. They handle sales and insertion; you get a cut. For newsletter creators who want to monetize through ads rather than products, this is valuable.
The analytics focus on content performance. You see which issues performed well, where subscribers came from, and how your growth trends over time. It’s designed for someone thinking like a publisher, not a marketer.
Where It Lacks
Beehiiv is weak on automation compared to ConvertKit. You can set up basic welcome sequences and segment sends, but there’s no visual automation builder. If your business model depends on complex funnels, product launches, or behavior-based sequences, Beehiiv won’t cut it.
The e-commerce integrations are limited. There’s no native shop, no product-specific features, and fewer third-party integrations overall. If you’re selling products or courses, you’ll need to connect other tools, and the process isn’t as smooth as ConvertKit’s ecosystem.
Beehiiv is also newer, which means the feature set is still expanding. Some things that feel standard elsewhere—like robust API access or deep analytics—are less mature here. The platform is iterating fast, but it’s not as battle-tested as the others.
Pricing Reality Check
All three platforms charge based on subscriber count, but the curves are different. Mailchimp gets expensive fastest. ConvertKit sits in the middle. Beehiiv offers the most runway before costs spike, especially if you’re focused purely on newsletter growth.
At 5,000 subscribers:
- Mailchimp Standard: $75/month
- ConvertKit: $66/month
- Beehiiv Scale: $39/month
At 10,000 subscribers:
- Mailchimp Standard: $138/month
- ConvertKit: $116/month
- Beehiiv Scale: $39/month
Beehiiv stays at $39/month until you hit 10,000 subscribers, which is a real advantage if you’re growing quickly. ConvertKit’s pricing is more predictable than Mailchimp’s but still scales with every tier. Mailchimp penalizes growth the most aggressively.
Integration and Workflow Considerations
Mailchimp integrates with nearly everything. E-commerce platforms, CRMs, social media tools, analytics software—if it exists, there’s probably a Mailchimp integration. This matters if you’re running a business with multiple tools and need them to talk to each other.
ConvertKit has solid integrations with creator-focused tools. Course platforms, membership sites, payment processors, and webinar software connect easily. If you’re in the creator economy ecosystem, the tools you use likely work with ConvertKit. For broader workflow automation, check out automation tools that don’t require coding.
Beehiiv’s integration library is smaller. It covers the basics—Zapier, webhooks, API access—but you won’t find as many native connections. For newsletter-focused creators, this usually isn’t a dealbreaker. For those running complex operations, it’s a gap.
Migration and Lock-In
All three platforms let you export your subscriber list. Moving between them is possible but not seamless. You’ll lose some data—automation sequences, tags, engagement history—and you’ll need to rebuild workflows.
ConvertKit and Beehiiv both offer migration support for larger lists. Mailchimp provides documentation but less hands-on help. If you’re starting out, don’t let migration fear paralyze you. Getting started matters more than picking the theoretically perfect platform. You can always move later if your needs change significantly.
Which One Fits You
Choose Mailchimp if: You’re running a product business, need extensive e-commerce integrations, or send varied types of marketing emails beyond newsletters. It’s overkill for pure newsletter creators but solid for broader business email needs. If you’re just starting and want to experiment with building an email list using free tools, the free tier works for basic testing.
Choose ConvertKit if: You’re a blogger, course creator, or digital product seller who needs automation and audience segmentation. It’s the best option if you plan to sell to your list, run launches, or create complex nurture sequences. The visual automation builder and creator-focused features justify the higher cost if your business model depends on them.
Choose Beehiiv if: You’re publishing a newsletter as your primary content vehicle and want the best writing and reading experience. The native referral program, built-in website, and aggressive free tier make it the obvious choice for newsletter-first creators. If automation and complex funnels aren’t central to your model, you’ll get more value for less money here.
The Practical Path Forward
Start with the free tier that gives you the most room to grow without paying. For most solo newsletter creators, that’s Beehiiv. For course creators and product sellers, it’s ConvertKit. For businesses needing broad integrations, it’s Mailchimp.
Don’t overthink the decision. The platform matters less than publishing consistently and growing your audience. You can switch later if your needs change. The real cost isn’t the monthly fee—it’s the time spent deliberating instead of creating.
Test the editor with a few drafts. Send a couple of emails to yourself. See which interface feels natural. The tool you’ll actually use beats the theoretically perfect tool you’ll resent opening.
For tracking what’s working once you’ve chosen a platform and started sending, consider these approaches for monitoring performance without needing a full marketing team.
The best email platform for a solo creator is the one that gets out of your way and lets you focus on writing, publishing, and connecting with your audience. Pick the tool that matches where you are now, not where you hope to be in three years. You can upgrade or switch when you actually need different features, not when you imagine you might.
Related: How Solopreneurs Use AI to Write Newsletters Faster

Pingback: Email Marketing Tools for Lists Under 5,000 Subscribers - Stackzilo